The Marian apparitions are far from the Word of God: here's why

image_pdfimage_print

I am publishing this article on the occasion of the Feast of the Immaculate Conception established by the Catholic Church over the centuries.

Since the Middle Ages the Catholic Church has received a very large number of testimonies of alleged supernatural manifestations. Although many of these demonstrations have been discredited or rejected in recent times, apparitions remain a particularly attractive element for Catholics. Several people in the past have reported seeing apparitions of various saints (such as in the case, recent, of Padre Pio). But the most frequent apparition of all is that of the Virgin Mary.

The most important Marian apparitions in history:

  • that of Guadalupe, Mexico (1531), where the devotion of “Our Lady of Guadalupe”;
  • that of Lourdes, France (1858), where 14-year-old Bernardette Soubirous claimed to have received 18 apparitions of the virgin Mary, who would have confided to her 3 “secrets” that she shouldn't have disclosed (recently there has also been talk of new revelations from Lourdes);
  • that of Fatima, Portugal (1917), dove 3 children would have been witnesses of 6 several appearances, receiving prophecies and visions; the message of Fatima is very similar to that of Lourdes, in regards to prayer and repentance, but it also explains how this is to happen: through the recitation of rosario e “the devotion of the whole world to the immaculate heart of Mary” (therefore not through faith in Christ, but through the Marian cult combined with the custom of reciting numerous prayers, that Jesus condemned in the gospel); the apparition declared, finally, to be “the Lady of the Rosary”;
  • what di Beauraing e Banneux, Belgium (1933), where they counted 33 apparitions of the one who called herself “the Immaculate Virgin”, “the Mother of God”, and the “Queen of Heaven”;
  • that of Bayside, New York (1970), where a housewife claimed to receive regular visits from “blessed virgin Mary”; the apparition was defined “Our Lord of the Roses, Mary help of mothers”, and he wanted a temple and a basilica to be built;
  • the most recent, that of Medjugorje, Yugoslavia (1981), dove 6 young Croatians claimed to communicate almost every day with an apparition who identified themselves as the “blessed virgin Mary”, and he encouraged the young people to say various Catholic prayers; Furthermore, Jesus would also appear to the young people, the devil, of angels, of dead relatives (a girl would also kiss the spirit of her dead mother, which the word of God condemns as necromancy), and they would have visions and received gods “secrets” and messages to be revealed in due course; until today, the number of such apparitions would come to 2500 circa;
  • and also those of: Bac street, Paris (1830); La Salette, France (1846); Pontmain, France (1871); e Knock, Ireland (1879).

A few comments on the question

From the study of these phenomena, it is evident that the only way in which the creed of the Marian apparitions can be justified is by accepting distinctly Catholic creeds, not biblical, his Maria. What is more serious, is the way the Mariology challenges the uniqueness of the person of Jesus Christ, and it belittles the complete sufficiency of His perfect redemptive work on the cross. Those who doubt this consider the way in which Mariology relates to Christology:

1) Jesus was born without sin — Mary would have been conceived without sin

2) Jesus was and is without sin — Mary would have lived a sinless life

3) After risen, Jesus ascended to heaven — Mary would be physically assumed into heaven

4) Jesus is the only Mediator — Maria would be the mediator

5) Jesus is the only Redeemer — Maria would be co-redemptrix

6) Jesus is the new Adam — Mary would be the new Eve

7) Jesus is the spotless Lamb — Mary would be the spotless lamb

8) Jesus is the King — Mary would be the Queen.

We can easily see how this parallel unfortunately aims to undermine the pre-eminence of Christ and His exclusive role as the only Redeemer and the only Mediator.. By virtue of his exalted state, Mary is represented as a semi-divine being and venerated as such.

Analyzing the miraculous events that accompany the Marian apparitions, it is clear how they turn out to be of a very different mold from those seen in the word of God. This is true of all biblical miracles and those of Jesus himself. When ever, eg, Jesus made the sun pulsate or rotate a cross on itself (two of the wonders of Medjugorje)? All of Jesus' miracles were done in the context of His ministry. And biblical miracles have a strong practical side. Many of the miracles associated with the Marian apparitions are, in contrast, dramatic and sensational; faces, practically, to attract attention – just the kind of miracles that Jesus categorically refused to do! (see Matteo 12:38-39). This is a good reason to be suspicious of the source of these miracles. We must also remember that the word of God severely condemns speaking with the dead. Any contact or revelation from them, whether it is Mary or another person, it is a communication with demons. The apostle Paul warns us that the devil “he knows how to disguise himself as an angel of light” (2 Corinthians 11:14-15), is capable of performing “powerful works, lying signs and wonders” (2 Tess. 2:9-10), and in the last times he will raise up false Christs and false prophets who “they will do great signs and wonders to seduce, if it were possible, even the elect” (Matteo 24:24). He is also able to predict the future (sometimes even with accuracy) and to declare a way to salvation other than the gospel of Jesus Christ. Its goal is always to distance man from Jesus Christ, precisely through religion, deviating from faith in Him as the one Savior and the only Mediator.

How does all this apply to Medjugorje and other popular Marian apparitions? The purpose of the Adversary behind this phenomenon is perhaps that of decentralize the faith of Catholics from Christ and from the biblical elements of Catholicism by placing the emphasis on the less biblical and more sectarian aspects of Catholicism (Mariology in general, penances, purgatory, the veneration of deceased saints). As long as the emphasis remains on these things, Satan can afford to sweeten his deceptions with a little’ of Christian theology – eg, telling the followers of the apparitions to pray, to work for peace, and so on.”Don't believe every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God:” (1 Giovanni 4:1). The fact that the entities that appeared in Lourdes and Fatima initially refused to reveal their identity raises not a few suspicions about who they really were.. And sprinkle holy water mixed with salt, as was done in the case of Medjudorje, it doesn't mean at all “try the spirits”, but it is only a useless tradition created by men. Whatever the cause, the effect of this phenomenon is to lead people away from the truth of , if we want to defend it from this kind of spiritual aberrations, the Word of the Lord must be our point of reference.The popularity of the apparitions shows us that millions of Catholics are genuinely hungry for spiritual truth. But the Truth, that which makes men free, it is found only in that Christ Jesus of which the apostolic writings speak, in our Lord Jesus. therefore, it is precisely out of respect for Christ and his Word – and out of true honor to his mother – that we reject the cult and the Marian apparitions.

Personal considerations

Believing in miracles and apparitions goes against God's Word, so be very careful not to fall into this grave sin, which surely is the work of the devil who wants to distract us from the true faith: God doesn't need to show himself, he does not show himself, we just have to believe in it and those who believe from the bottom of their hearts will be saved (regardless of the good works and the sacraments received, who established the Catholic Church and are therefore a tradition that have nothing to do with the Bible) And it must be remembered that the only and great mediator we have known and shown himself is Jesus Christ, just him and no one else, the others are impostors (demons). To pray to Mary is to make her a goddess capable of performing miracles and saving us, and the same goes for the saints, it is a grave affront to God, and what His commandment says???

Dall’Exodus 20 (i 10 commandments):

2 «I am the LORD, your God, that I brought you out of the land of Egypt, from the house of slavery.

3 Have no other gods besides me.

4 Don't make yourself sculpture, nor any image of the things that are in heaven above or on earth below or in the waters under the earth.

5 Do not bow down to them and do not serve them, why me, the Sir, your God, I am a jealous God; I punish the iniquity of fathers over their children up to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me,

6 and use goodness, up to the thousandth generation, towards those who love me and keep my commandments.

You may also like
21 comments
  1. Sandro dice

    I'm sorry, I have brought you back only a few verses; rereading the entire chapter, I realized that it is much more helpful to read it all. 😉

    1 Now, brothers, I declare to you the gospel that I have announced to you, and which you have received and in which you are steadfast, 2 and by which you are saved, if you hold firmly that word that I have announced to you, unless you have believed in vain. 3 In fact, I first of all transmitted to you what I also received, namely, that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, 4 who was buried and resurrected on the third day according to the scriptures, 5 and who appeared to Cephas and then to the twelve. 6 He later appeared at one time to more than five hundred brothers, most of which are still alive, while some are already asleep. 7 Later he appeared to James and then to all the apostles together. 8 finally, last of all, it also appeared to me as in abortion. 9 In fact, I am the least of the apostles and I am not even worthy of being called an apostle, because I persecuted God's church. 10 But by the grace of God I am what I am; and his grace towards me was not in vain, indeed, I struggled more than all of them, not me though, but the grace of God that is with me. 11 Or therefore, both me and them, so we preach, and so you believed. 12 Now, if it is preached that Christ has risen from the dead, why some of you say there is no resurrection of the dead? 13 So if there is no resurrection of the dead, not even Christ has risen. 14 But if Christ has not risen, therefore our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain. 15 Furthermore, we will find ourselves being false witnesses of God, for we have testified of God, that he resurrected Christ, while he would not have resurrected him, if truly the dead are not raised. 16 For if the dead do not rise again, not even Christ was resurrected; 17 but if Christ has not been resurrected, your faith is in vain; you are still in your sins, 18 and even those who sleep in Christ are lost. 19 If we hope in Christ only in this life, we are the most miserable of all men. 20 But now Christ has been raised from the dead, and it is the first fruits of those who sleep. 21 Indeed, as death came through a man, comes also through a man also came the resurrection of the dead. 22 Because, how everyone dies in Adam, thus all will be quickened in Christ, 23 but each in their own order: Christ the first fruits, then those who are Christ's at his coming. 24 Then the end will come, when he returns the kingdom into the hands of God the Father, after annihilating every domain, all authority and power. 25 In fact, he must reign, until he has put all enemies under his feet. 26 The last enemy to be destroyed is death. 27 For God has placed everything under his feet. But when he says that everything is subject to him, it is clear that the one who subjected everything to him is excepted. 28 And when everything is subjected to him, then the Son will also be subjected to the one who subjected everything to him, that God may be all in all. 29 Otherwise what will those who are baptized for the dead do? If the dead are not raised at all, for therefore they are baptized for the dead? 30 Because we too are in danger at all times? 31 I die every day for the pride of you, that I have in Christ Jesus, our Lord. 32 If I fought in Ephesus with fairs for human reasons, what a profit I have? If the dead are not raised, we eat and drink, because tomorrow we will die. 33 Do not be deceived; bad company corrupts good morals. 34 Return to being sober and upright and do not sin, because some have no knowledge of God; I say this to your shame. 35 But someone will say: “How the dead are raised, and with what body they will come?». 36 Fool! What you sow is not quickened, if it doesn't die first. 37 And as for what you sow, you do not sow the body that has to be born, but a naked grain, which may be of wheat or some other seed. 38 And God gives him a body as he has established, and to each seed he gives his own body. 39 Not all flesh is the same flesh; but the flesh of men is another, the flesh of beasts is another, the flesh of the fish is another, the meat of birds is another. 40 There are also celestial bodies, and of terrestrial bodies, but the glory of the heavenly is another, the other is that of the earthlings. 41 Another thing is the splendor of the sun, one the splendor of the moon and another the splendor of the stars, because a star differs from another star in brightness. 42 So will the resurrection of the dead also be; the body is sown in corruption and is raised in incorruption. 43 It is sown in shame and it is raised in glory; it is sown weak and it is raised full of strength. 44 It is sown natural body, and resurrects a spiritual body. There is natural body, and there is a spiritual body. 45 So it is also written: “The first man, Adamo, became a living soul "; but the last Adam is the Spirit who gives life. 46 But the spiritual is not before, but first is the natural, then the spiritual. 47 The first man, drawn from the earth, it is terrestrial; the second man, who is the Lord, it's from heaven. 48 What is the terrestrial so are the terrestrials; and what is the celestial, such will also be the celestial ones. 49 And how we brought the image of the terrestrial, we will also bring the image of the celestial. 50 Now this I say, brothers, that flesh and blood cannot inherit God's kingdom; similarly, corruption does not inherit incorruptibility. 51 here, I tell you a mystery: not all of us will die, but we will all be changed in a moment, 52 Suddenly, to the sound of the last trumpet; for the trumpet will sound, the dead will rise incorruptible and we will be changed, 53 since it is necessary that this corruptible clothes the incorruptibility and this mortal clothes the immortality. 54 So when this corruptible will have clothed incorruptibility and this mortal will have clothed immortality, then the word which was written will be fulfilled: "Death was swallowed up in victory". 55 The death, where is your dart? The hell, where is your victory? 56 Now the sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. 57 But thanks be to God who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ. 58 therefore, my dearest brothers, stand firm, adamant, continually abounding in the work of the Lord, knowing that your toil is not in vain in the Lord. (1Corinthian 15)

  2. Alessio Rando dice

    Why do you say that God does not work miracles? God still works miracles, certainly not those of the FALSE Marian apparitions. God does not rotate the sun in the sky, God works miracles consistent with His Word, the Holy Bible.

    1. ChristianFaith dice

      It still performs miracles, he heals by prayer, makes conversions, but not visible outward signs such as the turning sun, signs in the sky, sensations, prophecies of the Pentecostals and the alleged gifts of tongues now extinct by the time of the early church, as the apostle Paul said (1Corinthians 13:8-10). Matteo 16:4 “This wicked and adulterous generation is asking for a sign, and a sign will not be given to her except that of Jonah ". E, leave them, He left.”

      1. Alessio Rando dice

        But Paul does not say that the gifts of tongues will be abolished when perfection arrives (1 Corinthians 13:10)?

      2. ChristianFaith dice

        Exact! And perfection came with the end of the prophecies and the first apostles who spoke by inspiration of God, with the Apostle Paul and John concluding the Apocalypse. What is this perfection? You say Jesus. Certainly not! just read and reread the paragraph carefully paying attention to the context: Paul is pearling of the gospel message and knowledge. Now we have the knowledge, we have had it from the moment in which Scripture closed.(1 Corinthian 13:9-11) We have everything we need to be saved! E’ out of context to attribute the “perfection” to Jesus. This first. Second: except in that verse of Corinthians and that of Acts (where an Old Testament prophecy is being fulfilled, and a prophecy is fulfilled only once and not indefinitely), we have no other passages of Scripture that speak to us of these episodes of languages ​​and prophecies of Christians. E’ logical that it was an episode related to the first churches. Third, it is not said that if exorcisms are performed, it is prophesied or spoken in tongues, you are with God:

        “Not whoever tells me: lord, lord! he will enter the kingdom of heaven, but whoever does the will of my Father who is in heaven. Many will say to Me in that day: “lord, lord, we did not prophesy in your name and cast out demons in your name and do many mighty works in your name?” Then I will declare them: “I have never known you; get away from me, evildoers!” Matteo 7:21-23

        This is what happens inside the Pentecostal churches, where you scream, we cry, you throw yourself on the ground, nonsense phrases are stammered, everyone stands on his own and talks to himself , where no one interprets (something criticized by the apostle Paul always in Corinthians) It is not of God.

        I pentecostali, per me, they are not Protestants (and they don't even want to be called Protestants), because they do not follow any tradition or catechism of the Protestant Reformation, on the contrary, they disgusted it by pointing to the reformers as if they were the pope and the clergy. Pentecostals are a modern sect linked to sensationalism, of the Protestant world. Groups that attract crowds of the most ignorant and bona fide Christians, groups led by ignorant charismatic leaders, and many times fraudsters who even spiritually abuse the members of the church, pastors who are not even eighth grade and are not even able to read the Bible in its context.

      3. Alessio Rando dice

        Sorry ChristianFaith, but if those languages ​​spoken are not of God from who they are?
        What do you think of the exorcisms done by the Pentecostals? And you reformed do exorcisms?
        What is the besmmia against the Holy Spirit?

      4. Alessio Rando dice

        Sorry ChristianFaith, but if those languages ​​spoken are not of God from who they are?
        What do you think of the exorcisms done by the Pentecostals? And you reformed do exorcisms?
        What is the besmmia against the Holy Spirit?

      5. ChristianFaith dice

        Who I am from? Guess what'! Read this series of articles http://riforma.net/apologetica/pentecostalismo/index.htm
        I think that everything that happens in the Pentecostal churches is not of God, their hysterical behaviors and beliefs are not from the Bible. Exorcisms see them everywhere, they see demons everywhere, they have too much to do with the occult and this is very dangerous. The matrix of all this? First, psychological fixation and hysteria, second, the hand of the devil, but in very rare cases. Pentecostals do nothing but want to reach a goal: they pray to the Holy Spirit (that you do not pray) to have the gift of tongues. And just as it happens in the Catholic Church there are signs, but those signs are not from God but from the adversary. Jesus said he would no longer give SIGNS until he returned, and said he would leave us the consoling spirit. The apostle Paul said the gifts would run out shortly thereafter… in short, after all this, and after all that is seen in their churches, and after the answer of Jesus that says “go away from me evildoers, I never knew you:”, we can still doubt? Why Pentecostals ask for signs and behave like Catholics when faith in Jesus has already regenerated us and made us be born again? They do not realize they want more and this is not allowed? Very dangerous.
        The blasphemy against the holy spirit is the curse of the holy spirit. Don't tell me they make you believe that we others blaspheme the holy spirit, vero? They are the ones who use it too easily and always have it in their mouths… We must pray to the Father in the name of Jesus and leave the Holy Spirit alone, that you do not touch. Risk: Satan has a hand in it.

      6. Alessio Rando dice

        They told me that the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is apostasy.
        I need ChristianFaith advice: Since I frequent the Pentecostals I feel influenced and attacked by the devil, it might be because I'm hitting them?

      7. Alessio Rando dice

        therefore you who are not reformed do not believe in exorcisms? Yet if there is a demon, how do you free?

      8. ChristianFaith dice

        Of course we believe it! But these are quite rare cases, not as common as in Pentecostal churches, who see the devil everywhere and make a schizophrenia sufferer pass for a demon possessed perhaps by inculcating the devil in his brain! There will also be reformed pastors who perform exorcisms, of course.

      9. ChristianFaith dice

        We should see what they mean by apostasy!!! For Catholics, we are apostasy, for Pentecostals they are all who are not Pentecostals, etc. etc… No, the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is blaspheming the holy spirit, maledirlo, apostasy has nothing to do with it. And nobody here is blaspheming the holy spirit, neither us nor them!
        Absolutely yes, the fact that you feel haunted by the devil is because they are brainwashing you, same thing that jehovah's witnesses do! And the more you go on, the worse it will be! In their churches, they talk about nothing but the devil, makes this thing shiver: a Christian church is not made up of hysteria and chaos, but of peace and tranquility, as well as praise and silence, of contemplation and meditation. I told you years ago not to go to the Pentecostals but you didn't listen to me, what did you think I was joking???
        If you know English there are a myriad of sites of former Pentecostals, associations of people who come out of these sects, spiritually abused who feel like former Jehovah's Witnesses. Unfortunately in Italy these evangelicals are the majority and they do not realize the danger they run, as well as the falsehoods of the doctrines that are instilled in him by the pastor on duty, which has divine and infallible jurisdictional power!!!
        http://www.ex-pentecostals.org
        http://www.spiritualabuse.org
        http://www.recoveringpentecostal.com
        http://www.rapidnet.com/~jbeard/bdm/Psychology/char/charisma.htm
        http://www.monergism.com/directory/link_category/Spiritual-Gifts/
        http://www.monergism.com/directory/link_category/Baptism/Baptism-of-the-Holy-Spirit/
        http://www.scionofzion.com/18dangers.htm
        http://www.biblebelievers.com/montgomery/montgomery001.html

      10. ChristianFaith dice

        The Salvation Army is the same thing!

      11. Alessio Rando dice

        Why do you say it's the same thing? I don't think they speak in tongues?!

      12. ChristianFaith dice

        Not in the sense that they speak in tongues, as they are of Methodist origin (even if the neopentecostalism has penetrated in all the churches, even those of the reform), I mean in the sense that the whole thing does not convince me! Anyway why do you always ask me about this army of salvation? They are humanitarian aid, schools, methods of evangelization, organizations, they welcome all Christian confessions, they are like the catholic caritas in a way, nothing to do with evangelical denominations. I have never even looked into it because I don't care, in reality there is nothing to investigate.

      13. Alessio Rando dice

        ok

      14. Alessio Rando dice

        So everything that comes from modalism is wrong?

      15. ChristianFaith dice

        We are off topic. If you need specific answers, post your question in the section “Ask a question” at the top of the navigation bar, and as soon as possible I publish an answer article in the FAQs section.

      16. Alessio Rando dice

        ok

      17. Alessio Rando dice

        Sorry ChristianFaith, but if those languages ​​spoken are not of God from who they are?
        What do you think of the exorcisms done by the Pentecostals? And you reformed do exorcisms?
        What is the besmmia against the Holy Spirit?

Leave a reply

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read more

You are in search of truth? You want peace of mind and certainty? Visit the section questions & Answers!

X